Powerhouse strategies

This year’s strategic statement from northern mayors and government prioritised a Manchester-Liverpool new line, Leeds-Sheffield electrification, and at top of list a new station to replace Bradford Interchange. The Bradford station proposal is welcome – provided, that is it means a genuine through station to replace Interchange, slashing journey times between Leeds and Calderdale. Halifax-Leeds could come down to just over 20 minutes. That on its own will require some major works on the south side of Bradford city centre.

Departures 06:42 Chester Page 1 of 2 Expt 07:27 via Halifax Via Elland first stop Sowerby Bridge today… 07:02 York 7A Delayed Delayed due to a train fault…
Well, here’s a thing at Leeds! The Chester train is late coming from depot. So it’s going to miss out Bradford and Halifax and run non-stop to Sowerby Bridge – via Elland! They couldn’t put Brighouse or people might think it was stopping there. But “via Halifax” is unlikely as first stop is Sowerby Bg! And is the “Bradford Inter” train a diverted Brighouse line service being held to run all stations to Bradford via Halifax? We couldn’t find it in the timetable. Any thoughts?

Plans must involve the mass-transit scheme. But they must not depend on it or we could be waiting some time, while the trams proposal goes through its present government-demanded reassessment. Third phase of the plan could be a new high speed route Bradford-Huddersfield. When this was first made public more than two years ago, rumour had it a route through Bailiff Bridge was being considered. Improbable? But we are not clear where it would go. It certainly is not expected to serve Calderdale. And planning will take generation. Can we wait that long? Our line, across the Pennines through both Halifax and Brighouse needs improvements now. We have talked about Bradford-Sheffield trains hinted at in West Yorkshire Combined Authority’s rail strategy. We shall continue to advocate that proposal, which even if routed via Wakefield initially would provide an attractive link Halifax, Brighouse and Mirfield to Meadowhall and Sheffield. Longer term route could be via Barnsley, target journey time Brighouse to Sheffield 50 minutes. (Which would require reopening of the Crigglestone curve.) Also in WYCA’s rail strategy was an extra service every hour Elland-Brighouse-Leeds. The extra train could be fast, Brighouse-Leeds 20 minutes. All trains through Brighouse should serve Elland, of course. The “extra” could start from Halifax, and could be balanced by continuing to run one trans-Pennine each hour to York via Wakefield and Castleford. Demand has been proven – not rocket science. Hourly TPE trains already run this way, and it should be kept. When we raised it at this year’s TPE stakeholder conference in January, Northern and TPE speakers seemed to pour cold water on the idea. We have not given up on this. Who wants to go back to a Huddersfield-Castleford shuttle? Finally, we need a half-hourly fast service Bradford-Halifax-Rochdale-Manchester, extra to present trains (including extra stops for Sowerby Bg at least). Linespeed and capacity upgrades would be needed, but mean the new extra trains would take 45 minutes or less Bradford-Manchester. Achievable much sooner than a new line Bradford to Huddersfield.

Bradford NPR Station Worry

NORTHERN Powerhouse Rail envisions a high- speed rail line through “central” Bradford. Calder Valley line trains would also use the station, no longer having to reverse and do the final leg Bradford-Leeds in ten minutes or less. In March Bradford council revealed a proposal to build the station on the site of council-owned St James’s market. This would be in the middle of a new southern gateway development – but outside the present inner ring road probably a 10 minute walk from today’s city-centre “gateway” at Hall Ings, another five minutes or so from the media museum, Alhambra theatre and markets area.

You could stay on the train and be in Leeds quicker!

In our response to the WY strategy HADRAG, and other groups including Yorkshire Railfuture, have marked this as a serious concern.

Bradford’s NPR ‘Plan on a Page’

Infrastructure Questions

Imagine your Calder Valley train pauses briefly in a new Bradford station, no longer reverses there as they do now, but runs high-speed Bradford-Leeds. Halifax-Leeds could be under 20 minutes.

In its submission last summer to the National Infrastructure Commission, West Yorkshire Combined Authority called for the Leeds-Bradford section of Northern Powerhouse Rail to be brought forward, with a new central Bradford station serving both NPR and Calder Valley. WYCA also prioritised Calder Valley electrification.

NIC’s final report seems to offer Government (who will decide) the choice of either the eastern (Leeds) arm of HS2 or a focus on regional enhancements. NPR Leeds-Bradford-Manchester is shown in a regional package with a “+50%” budget. At “+25%” NPR high speed is lost but Leeds-Bradford is upgraded and the Huddersfield route gets “some new line”. Packages delivering HS2 east kill regional new lines. All packages propose HS2 west through to Manchester (continuing to Leeds if NPR is built).

NIC wants the plan to contribute to net-zero: “The Integrated Rail Plan should include a rolling programme of electrification to help decarbonise the railways…” and “help deliver industry efficiencies… ”(p66). As we keep saying.

HADRAG has also said if a new Leeds-Bradford-Manchester line comes through Calderdale, then Calderdale should have a station on it. A straight, mainly tunnelled route Bradford-Manchester could go underneath Halifax! Where would it cross the Calder Valley? Tunnel or viaduct? Without their own station, would local people be happy? – JSW

See also: Rail Needs Assessment for the Midlands and the North: Final report – NIC

And:

https://westyorkshire.moderngov.co.uk/documents/s16325/Item%2 07%20-%20Appendix%201%20-%20NIC%20-%20final%20response.pdf


Featured Image: “Azuma Offord Cluny” flickr photo by kitmasterbloke https://flickr.com/photos/kitmasterbloke/49259604572 shared under a Creative Commons (BY) license